When Leah Cassidy has a one-night stand with a guy dressed up as a skeleton at a Halloween party, she writes it off as a momentary lapse of judgment. Unfortunately, that lapse comes back to her when she finds out that she is pregnant.
When bigshot defense attorney Benjamin O'Connor meets a gorgeous redhead named Leah in the rain just outside the courthouse, he is instantly smitten with her, which has never happened to him before. They meet again in a strange twist of fate, and Benjamin knows that he should take his chance before it's too late.
As Leah starts to fall for Ben, she musters up the courage to tell him about the pregnancy.
Will he freak out and leave like most of the men she had dated, or will he man up and be a father to a child that isn't even his?